Monday, November 28, 2005

happy non-euclidean holidays!

Lileks' geometric analysis of Christmas music where:
"...the various members of the family gather to rock around the Christmas tree. How this rocking is done I am unsure, since the tree is usually in the corner; thus it would be difficult to rock around the Christmas tree. You would have to rock in a semi-circular pattern. The people on the end would either have to circle around the others, which would mean they were rocking around the persons rocking, or the entire line would have to shift back and forth, permitting the occupant of the center position no more than a few feet of rocking. It is also unclear what sort of rocking we are talking about here; most rocking doesn’t take you around anything. From the Bruce Springsteen grin-and-thrust-and-pump-hip dance to the Foghat-stoner stand-in-place-and-bob-head style, most rocking is done in place. So the whole song falls apart under analysis. Note: it is possible to rock around the clock, this being an expression of rocking performed in time, not space."

2 comments:

Sanctimonious Hypocrite said...

I always think of the Whos down in Whoville, holding hands in a circle and kind of tipping from side to side as they sing.

sackofcatfood said...

Perhaps the ACLU stole their Christmas tree....